Skip to main content
HomeDale Smith Online

Reviews

Main navigation

  • Write Fan Fiction
    • Cosmic Masque
    • Back From the Dead
    • Charity Anthologies
    • Myth Makers
    • Shelf Life
  • Enter Competitions
    • Hello?
    • A Night on the Tiles
    • Skin Deep
  • Send Out Stories
    • Brief Encounters
    • A Northamptonshire Tale
    • Heritage
    • The Albino's Dancer
    • The Panda Book of Horror
    • In Uniform
    • The Black Archive #58
  • Get Rejected
    • Wolfsong
    • Kaldor City
    • Time, Unincorporated
  • Get Asked to Write
    • The Kissing Game
    • The Lunatic
    • The Solar System
    • Red
    • Collected Works
    • Time and Relative Dissertations in Space
    • Cut
    • The Many Hands
    • Transmissions
    • Wildthyme in Purple
    • Tales of the City
    • Iris Wildthyme of Mars
    • Big Finish Short Trips
    • The Perennial Miss Wildthyme
    • Spinning Jenny
    • Build High For Happiness
Utility menu

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Get Asked to Write
  3. Collected Works
  4. Reviews

This is the story where you can quote lines to people and where the writing absolutely sparkles.

Stuart Douglas

There is a tradition of Doctor Who short story anthologies having a linked theme, which was upheld by the tangentially connected Bernice Summerfield collections. This added an extra layer of work for the editors – it wasn’t enough for the book to have a fair number of good stories: the framework story had to be compelling too. Unfortunately, this was one of the areas where some reviewers found Collected Works lacking: Henry Potts thought the linked narrative just didn’t work (and didn’t like the prevalence of adventures tales in the book); Stuart Douglas felt that the collection never settled on a single key theme and so struggled to come together as a whole … an opinion shared, in hindsight, by its editor Nick Wallace.

However, Collected Works has a rating of 3 and a bit stars on GoodReads and 4 on LibraryThing, and Doctor Who Magazine called it “An interesting, varied, and sometimes uncomfortable, mix”. Robert McGinlay said “Collected Works is definitely a collection that works” and gave it 8 out of 10, picking Mother’s Ruin as one of his favourites.

The writing style is fluid, flavorsome and full of life, mixing together humour with danger … Wonderful.

Ian Mond

Tags

    • reviews
Cover of Bernice Summerfield: Collected Works

Main (primary) menu

  • Doctor Who Magazine
  • Henry Potts
  • Ian Mond
  • Sci Fi Online
  • Stuart Douglas

Share me:

Footer menu

  • About me
  • Contact Me
  • Copyright
  • Search
Drupal icon
Goodreads icon
Mastodon icon