Dale Smith’s As A Kang Should Be is a triumph of layered storytelling and thematic ambition. Set in the dystopian confines of Paradise Towers – originally introduced in the Doctor Who story of the same name – the novel transcends its roots to become a searing, deeply human examination of bureaucracy, rebellion and identity in isolation. Smith brings the setting to life with striking realism and grim satire, exposing the cracks beneath the glossy slogans of “Build High for Happiness.” Told from multiple perspectives – among them a weary Caretaker clinging to rules as a lifeline, and a vibrant, defiant Kang named Downspout – the story unfolds through vivid, often contradictory voices that immerse the reader in the Towers’ collapsing social order. The narrative cleverly mimics found footage, security logs and personal testimony, making the horror of the events feel disturbingly real. It’s Orwellian, yes – but also oddly hopeful, with its bold young voices refusing to be silenced.
Smith’s command of tone is remarkable. He captures the institutional absurdity of Caretaker bureaucracy with dark humor while also delivering raw emotional punches that linger. The novel is unafraid to interrogate gender identity, memory and systemic neglect in ways that feel both timely and timeless. The dialogue is especially strong – sharp, distinctive, and often heart-breakingly human.
Fans of Stephen Wyatt’s original Paradise Towers story will find this novel an inspired expansion, but newcomers to this world need not worry either. Smith’s narrative is accessible, gripping and powerful on its own merits. Whether you’re here for world-building, character drama or biting social commentary, this book will have something for you.
A bold, brilliant exploration of dystopia through the lens of both satire and sincerity, As A Kang Should Be is one of the most original pieces of Doctor Who-related fiction I’ve read – and perhaps one of the most necessary. It’s highly recommended.
Chris McAuley, Celestial Toyroom 553