Skip to main content
Cover of The Black Archive #66
Home
Dale Smith Online

Reviews

  • Write Fan Fiction
    • Cosmic Masque
    • Back From the Dead
    • Charity Anthologies
    • Myth Makers
    • Shelf Life
  • Enter Competitions
    • Hello?
    • A Night on the Tiles
    • Skin Deep
  • Send Out Stories
    • Brief Encounters
    • A Northamptonshire Tale
    • Heritage
    • The Albino's Dancer
    • The Panda Book of Horror
    • In Uniform
    • The Black Archive #58
    • Joy
    • The Black Archive #66
  • Get Rejected
    • Wolfsong
    • Kaldor City
    • Time, Unincorporated
  • Get Asked to Write
    • The Kissing Game
    • The Lunatic
    • The Solar System
    • Red
    • Collected Works
    • Time and Relative Dissertations in Space
    • Cut
    • The Many Hands
    • Transmissions
    • Wildthyme in Purple
    • Tales of the City
    • Iris Wildthyme of Mars
    • Big Finish Short Trips
    • The Perennial Miss Wildthyme
    • Spinning Jenny
    • Build High For Happiness
Utility menu

Breadcrumb

  1. Home
  2. Send Out Stories
  3. The Black Archive #66
  4. Reviews

Too much initial JN-T mud-slinging sours an otherwise varied collection of ideas.

Nick Joy, SF Bulletin

As is a constant refrain on this site, books from small presses don’t get a lot of attention when it comes to things like reviews. The Black Archives are no different, and I can count on the fingers of one hand the places I can expect to see The Greatest Show in the Galaxy reviewed. One of them is SF Bulletin, and I look forward to seeing what they make of Obverse’s output, whether or not it’s me that has written it. So on this occasion it was a little disappointing to read their review of Black Archive #66.

Before you get the popcorn, I’m not about to complain about the review’s opinion of my book: I doubt this will be the worst thing someone thinks about the book, and the quality of a book is entirely down to the opinion of the person reading it, and at least SFB didn’t say it was “bollocks, frankly”. However, reading this review might give you an incorrect view of one of the sources I used for my Black Archive, Richard Marson’s excellent Totally Tasteless: The Life of John Nathan-Turner. 

To say this book is controversial (both within and without fandom) would be an understatement, but accusations of it being sensationalist and kicking John Nathan-Turner only because he cannot refute the allegations made in it - whilst not unique to this review - mischaracterise the book, it’s author and the careful work done to evidence, contextualise and desensationalise its reporting of John Nathan-Turner and Gary Downie’s abuse of their positions within fandom and the BBC. Marson was very careful to let the people making the allegations do so in their own words, and never let an emotive subject get away from him, despite being one of the pair’s victims. To dismiss the book as salacious gossip does a great disservice to those people brave enough to share their stories for no benefit to themselves, and Marson’s efforts to paint a full and fair picture of John Nathan-Turner. It’s disappointing to find myself - however tangentially - linked to this misreading of Marson’s work, and I can only apologise to Richard Marson for bringing this up again, even in such a small way.

So as a palate cleanser, it was very pleasing to read Evan Jones’ review on GoodReads, who as well as being very complimentary went to the trouble of reviewing it in the style of the Ringmaster’s rap. Top marks, and well worth the effort involved in me writing the book.

There is nothing in here that I’d really want to change
It’s another fab addition to the Black Archive book range.
So I suggest you buy this book in case you might forget
Whatever you’ve read before, you ain’t read nothing yet.

Evan Jones
Cover of The Black Archive #66

Main (primary) menu

  • Good Reads
  • Library Thing
  • SciFi Bulletin
  • The TARDIS Library

Share me:

Mastodon icon

Footer menu

  • About me
  • Contact Me
  • Copyright
  • Search
Drupal icon
Goodreads icon
Mastodon icon